Why plus-size women turn to men’s exercise clothing
By Darin Watkins, The Edward R. Murrow College of Communication
PULLMAN, Wash. – A lack of fashion options has plus-size women turning to men’s exercise clothing. That’s the conclusion of a study at Washington State University recently published in the journal Fashion and Textiles.
The study found that exercising is increasingly a challenge when large women can’t find activewear in their sizes and that many instead resort to menswear and/or cease to be active.
“The plus-size women we recruited for the study were active,” said Nicole O’Donnell, a Ph.D. student in WSU’s Edward R. Murrow College of Communication and co-author of the study. “Many of them talked about hiking, attending exercise classes, swimming, biking and walking/running. But not having exercise clothing readily available in their sizes was discouraging and was seen as a barrier to participating in these activities.”
Lack of options hinders activity
Led by Deborah Christel, assistant professor in the WSU Department of Apparel, Merchandising, Design and Textiles, the study interviewed dozens of plus-size women about what they wear for exercise, how they perceive clothing availability and how satisfied or dissatisfied they are with exercise clothes. The results revealed they often wear men’s clothing when exercising because of the lack of options in their sizes in the women’s department.
“Plus-size women make up the majority in the U.S.,” Christel said. “The fashion industry needs to increase access to affordable exercise clothing in more diverse sizes.”
Most popular athletic brands rarely offer sizes larger than XL for women. For example, one top exercise apparel company was found to offer eight items in its women’s plus-size line compared to more than 2,000 items in its women’s smaller sizes. In addition, the same company offered more than 200 items up to size 4XL for men.
“There’s a stereotype in our culture that if a woman is plus-size, it must mean that she is inactive,” said O’Donnell.
On the contrary, “the women we interviewed wanted to feel feminine and be active at the same time,” Christel said. “Sadly, the fashion industry isn’t providing clothing that satisfies the consumer. The product, price, promotion and placement aren’t right.
“The fashion industry isn’t helping larger women right now,” she said. “If anything, it is hindering larger women from being active.”
Clothing tied to identity, expression
While the findings focused on the challenges plus-size women face with exercise clothing, there are broader implications for society regarding perceptions of size. Numerous studies have determined that overweight or obese women are responded to more negatively than thin people.
“A woman is still, unfortunately, measured by her looks and how she fits into the cultural norms of femininity,” said co-author Linda Bradley, professor in WSU’s AMDT department. “Women are expected to be small and men big. The ramifications of being overweight are huge for women but, ironically, an overweight man is not as vilified.”
“Clothing is a powerful way to express one’s identity,” Christel said. “Women we spoke with felt personally responsible for not having exercise clothing available in their size.
“I think everyone has a social responsibility to encourage healthy behaviors,” she said. “Obese women are not provided with the exercise clothing they want and, as a result, they are less likely to exercise and more likely to feel compromised in their personal expression.”
Promoting fashion and health
Christel’s research focuses on plus-size design, functional design, post-bariatric clothing issues and weight bias in the fashion industry. She is actively working to improve aspects of fit, design and the shopping experience for plus-size women.
O’Donnell, who works with the WSU Murrow Center for Media and Health Promotion, teamed with Christel and Bradley because research on this issue has both fashion and health communication implications.
“One of our goals at the center is to find ways to effectively communicate and promote an active lifestyle,” O’Donnell said.
The paper, “Coping by crossdressing: An exploration of exercise clothing for obese, heterosexual women,” can be found at http://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s40691-016-0063-z.
Deborah Christel, WSU AMDT, 509-335-7453, Deborah_christel@wsu.edu
Nicole O’Donnell, WSU Edward R. Murrow College of Communication, 509-335-1556, Nicole.email@example.com
Linda Arthur Bradley, WSU AMDT, 509-335-7890, Linda.firstname.lastname@example.org
Editor’s note: Video and photos available at https://murrow.wsu.edu/news-events/plus-size-fashion.html.