Helping profs find just the right words in grading

You take a sip of wine. Your host asks, “How do you like it?” You say, “I like it” or “It’s not good.” You responded, but have you given good clues as to what you really meant?

Was your merlot “deliciously fruity with a hint of wood” or “too spicy and flowery” for your taste?

Grading writing by students is a lot like that, says Lisa Johnson-Shull, co-director of the WSU Writing Program. To help students communicate more effectively on each successive paper, professors could use a vocabulary that is clear yet descriptive enough to inspire change and growth.

So she’s offering a new workshop, “Wine Tasting as a Metaphor for Responding to Student Writing: Aroma Wheels, Rubrics and Other Frameworks of Noticing,” set for 2-4 p.m. Friday, May 8, in Webster Physical Science building’s 12th floor lounge.

The workshop is free and open to everyone age 21 and up, though space is limited, says Johnson-Shull; RSVPs are required to

or 335-5898.

Faculty who teach Writing in the Major courses would find the workshop appropriate. The Writing in the Disciplines unit within the Writing Program aids in the development and manages the review of more than 300 writing-intensive M courses across the disciplines.

“As workshops go, I believe this one is as useful as it is unique…and the atmosphere is convivial,” Johnson-Shull says. Participants will taste wines and describe them, then receive tips and tools to enhance their evaluations and help them refine what they mean.

“We give them what I call a ‘framework for noticing’ and it can be both illuminating and expanding,” she says. It is also applicable to other situations where full-bodied descriptions are more helpful, such as in evaluating students’ writing.

Johnson-Shull has tried out the wine-tasting-as-metaphor format twice before with graduate students and once at a conference for writing professionals in New Orleans. 

“It has proven to be informative as well as fun and creative, and participants have had very good discussions about how those who grade writing might boost the impact of their efforts by simply choosing the right words,” she says.

The May 8 event will be the first time the workshop is open to a wider audience at WSU. It is the annual spring workshop sponsored by the Writing in the Disciplines team.

Next Story

Recent News

Aging societies more vulnerable to collapse

Societies and political structures, like the humans they serve, appear to become more fragile as they age, according to an analysis of hundreds of pre-modern societies.

Insider will return Monday, Nov. 27

WSU Insider is taking a break to join with the rest of the university community in celebrating the Thanksgiving holiday. We’ll be back the morning of Nov. 27 with fresh posts and all the latest WSU information.

Charting a clear path forward for WSU Athletics

Statement from WSU President Kirk Schulz and Director of Athletics Pat Chun about today’s ruling affirming that the future of the Pac‑12 should be determined by the members who remain in the conference rather than those who are leaving.

Marshall Scholar finalist Katy Ayers explores fungi

WSU senior Katy Ayers, a bioengineering major minoring in biochemistry and mathematics, is the latest finalist for a Marshall Scholarship to study in the United Kingdom.