WSU graduate researcher Karen Hills. (Photos
by Brian Clark, WSU CAHNRS)
MOUNT VERNON, Wash. – Wheat growers west of the Cascades could bring in more profit by supplying wheat to local bakers, according to a recent survey conducted by Washington State University graduate researcher Karen Hills.
Sixty percent of western Washington commercial bakers said they are interested in purchasing locally sourced wheat and flour for their products. Those bakers use five million pounds of non-local flour annually.
“For the world of grain on the west side, that’s a significant number,” said Hills, based out of the WSU Mount Vernon Northwestern Washington Research and Extension Center. “As the local grain movement goes forward, this will be useful information for growers. I want this information to further the local grain movement on this side of the state.”
Connecting growers, bakers
In Washington, agricultural communities usually rely on large commodity supply chains for marketing their crops, especially small grains, Hills said. In addition, wheat is primarily grown as a rotation crop in northwestern Washington counties, with little economic return for growers.
Wheat trial growing at the WSU Mount
Vernon Northwestern Washington Research
and Extension Center.
Yet the region’s consumers are passionate about eating locally grown food. West side commercial bakers not only supply a means for getting local grain to consumers, but they also serve as one measure of consumer interest.
Ironically, most of these bakers must order organic wheat and flour from outside the region.
“The local food movement here made sense to study, but so much of the research on local foods was geared toward produce and livestock,” Hills said. “Local grain production and bakers’ perspectives about it hadn’t been explored. So I thought they would be a good addition.”
Concerns, barriers considered
Hills also wanted to learn what bakers were most concerned about when considering future purchases of regionally produced flour, what the barriers would be to using it and what they considered “local.”
She and Jessica Goldberger, a WSU rural sociologist in Pullman, developed a questionnaire to obtain the information, as well as demographics about bakery locations, distribution, percentage of sales direct to customers and whether flour was milled on-site.
Last March, Hills surveyed more than 250 commercial bakers from 19 counties west of the Cascade Mountains; 73 completed the questionnaire. Those surveyed were required to live in western Washington, purchase flour or wheat berries and produce a broad range of bread and pastries. Eliminated from the pool were bakeries that are part of large national chains or that sell cakes, cupcakes, donuts or pies exclusively.
Quality, supply, price important
While 60 percent of the respondents were interested in purchasing wheat or flour from western Washington, 36 percent indicated they didn’t know, which Hills said she wasn’t surprised to see. Only three percent answered no.
“There’s a lot of uncertainty because (local) wheat and flour are not widely available at this point,” she said. “That came through in other parts of the survey.”
draws from 15 states
To showcase efforts to spark more interest in local grain systems, WSU NWREC hosted the inaugural Kneading Conference West in September. It drew 250 participants from 15 states and two Canadian provinces to attend workshops on baking, milling, farming and malting.
Jones and Hills were presenters at the conference, and Hills discussed her survey findings on a panel for small-scale grain growing that included bakery owners.
Surveyed bakers listed consistency of flour quality, a reliable supply, price and flavor as their top factors for purchasing regionally produced wheat and flour in the future. The top barriers that would prevent them from doing so were cost, availability/quantity, suppliers/delivery, quality (gluten and protein content) and climate.
“Some of these factors would be greatly affected by the scale of flour processing and become more favorable for the bakers as the volume of western Washington flour processing increased,” Hills noted.
Asked to define “local” wheat, 43 percent of bakers answered wheat grown within state boundaries. But Hills said she also received a wide spectrum of responses, ranging from within the Pacific Northwest to a specific county.
Reviving west side heritage
Hills’ research ties in with the work of her advisor Stephen Jones, a wheat geneticist at and director of the WSU NWREC. He is working with local growers to bring back a once-prolific west side wheat growing heritage. Jones and others have identified 163 wheat varieties grown in the Pacific Northwest between the 1840s and 1955.
They are crossing these historical varieties with modern ones to come up with wheat breeds best suited for growing in wet, cool coastal climates that also can resist diseases, compete with weeds and produce high yields.
“It’s not that we can’t grow grains here,” Hills said. “We have so many options for growing food here. There’s an excitement around rejuvenating a tradition that was important here 100 years ago and reclaiming something that was lost.”
For more information about the WSU NWREC plant breeding program, visit http://plantbreeding.wsu.edu.